By a Concerned Parent
This past Erev Shabbos, at 4 PM, I left my home with my five-year-old son to run some last-minute errands. As we stepped outside, my son, full of excitement, ran ahead of me and out onto the sidewalk. In an instant, two boys zooming by on an electric scooter collided with him. My heart sank as I saw him thrown two feet across the pavement, with the bloodstains marking where the impact occurred.
His head was bleeding from two gashes caused by the scooter’s handlebars, and his face, having hit the sidewalk with force, was scraped, bruised, and bloodied; his arm was also injured. In a panic, I immediately called Hatzolah and pulled my son back inside. Baruch Hashem, he was conscious, and Hatzolah was on the way.
The boy responsible for the accident remained on the scene, visibly shocked by what had happened. My parental instincts took over, and I began demanding why he had been riding so carelessly. His response “It wasn’t my fault. Your son ran onto the sidewalk.” I reminded him that riding an electric scooter on the sidewalk is dangerous. His defense was, “Should I ride in the street? That’s dangerous!”
From his answer, I understood that his parents had forbidden him from riding in the street under any circumstances, and therefore, the responsibility for this accident lies with his parents.
When Hatzolah arrived, they carefully examined my son and transported us to the hospital. The staff there treated his injuries, removing the small pebbles embedded in his face and putting staples in his head. This was a painful and traumatic experience for a little boy.
Later, I received video footage of the boys on their scooters. They weren’t riding at top speed, but they weren’t going slowly either. Hashem Yishmor—if they had been moving faster, the outcome could have been much worse, Chas Vesholom.
I tracked down the parents of the boy involved and spoke with them about the incident. It turns out they had purchased the scooter to help their son reach yeshiva on time, and also as a fun accessory unaware of the potential dangers an electric scooter poses. Their ignorance of the hazard their child’s “fun accessory” poses was alarming. I’m sorry, but no child’s fun or convenience can justify another child’s injuries—or anyone for that matter.
Electric scooters do not belong on sidewalks, period. They are a danger to pedestrians, especially children and the elderly.
In this past week’s parsha, we learned about the mitzvah of Ma’akeh, which is our obligation to prevent dangerous situations from occurring. The safety of others is a fundamental Torah value – Lo Samod Al Dam Roecha -“Don’t stand by idly when your brother’s safety is at risk”.
Unfortunately, this is not an isolated incident. Electric scooters are becoming a growing danger on our sidewalks. We, as a community, must take action to get these scooters off our sidewalks. If someone chooses to endanger themselves by riding in the street, that’s their decision—but don’t endanger innocent pedestrians.
Additionally, it wouldn’t hurt for our teens and children to learn the value of walking and exercise. These habits are not only beneficial for physical health but also play a crucial role in our mental well-being. Let’s prioritize safety and ensure that our sidewalks remain safe, where both all can walk without fear.
Agree with everything.
we all agree until a 10 year old CHVSH gets hit by a vehicle who didnt see the kid in his blindspot and dies. get real.
You’ve missed the point entirely. Anyone with an ounce of common sense who walks around crown heights knows that kids zipping around on scooters is bad enough. But you make them electric and it’s deadly C”V. On top of that, parents clearly aren’t teaching the basics of safety (ie if you’re on the scooter it’s your responsibility to watch for pedestrians).
don’t ride electric scooters
especially on the streets
it’s dangerous
don’t bike on the streets either
Thank you for this well written article to bring awareness .
You bring you a lot of good points.
I’m so sorry you had to go through this.
There is no need for electric scooters, a regular scooter is good enough! What happened to good old walking to school? The boys have to learn to wake up early enough to get there in time, my son included.
Walk! It’s good exercise.
These days with his CH is expanding some boys live a half an hour walk away or more
Be thankful that HASHEM gave you two feet and use them in good health. Its for everyones benefit. Enough with the הפקירות !!!
I understand and agree that electric scooters r very dangerous, especially if they r rode on the side walk, too fast, recklessly, or with two people on it. I myself have got into an accident and got hurt badly, but the flame between my scooter and I will not be diminished because my scooter makes my life easier, every single day. It’s the best purchase I’ve made (I’m a teen dw). My theory is that the pros outweigh the cons. I just think that before a parent allows they’re child to ride one/u buy urself one, it shud be made… Read more »
She seems a lot more self aware and responsible than most teens
The thrust of the article should be: We must forbid our children from riding scooters, not, We must get scooters out the sidewalks.
If children ride scooters, I much prefer they ride on the sidewalk. In due time, your son (may his wounds heal speedily) will want a scooter. I hope you will say no. But if you say yes, I sure as heck hope that he rides on the sidewalk, rather than in the street despite the risk of injuring pedestrians.
Very true. On the street it can be life threatening,
Why is the safety of pedestrians which include children less important to you? If you use a scooter – go slow in the presence of pedestrians or wherever they can appear – for everyone’s safety! That means NO
SPEEDING on the sidewalk!
A sidewalk is for walking.
If you want to ride a vehicle at a faster speed than a walk, you ride it on the designated bike lane or in the street. If it’s too dangerous to ride on the street, then you don’t ride it all.
You have no right to endanger the lives of pedestrians because you don’t want to endanger your own life by riding on the street where you belong.
I think you made the most important points: Thank you!
Well-written article.
Hopefully being right will bring the right behaviour.
Moving vehicles do not belong in sidewalks.
Pedestrians belong on sidewalks.
This is aside for the fact that they are dangerous for the rider. A bochur in Crown heights riding one of these who had an accident on the side walk last week is in hospital in critical condition and had to have major surgery
And I can’t count How Many times I’ve seen scooter-riders (and bike-riders) ‘wearing’ a helmet, but it’s actually just sitting upon their heads with the chin-strap dangling below their chin. TOTALLY useless if they fall off their ‘vehicle’.
We must also include the drivers of mopeds used for deliveries for stores which are also riding on the sidewalks. Bikes, scooters, electrical scooters, mopeds and delivery vehicles do not belong on our sidewalks. There should be an enforcement of how to prohibit this.
Yeah it’s scary when I think that these zooming delivery goyim are going to crash into me
There are no bike lanes in Crown Heights, and it is very hard to get around by car as well.
Boruch Hashem your son is ok & as you wrote not worse Chas Vsholom!
May his injuries heal
This is the law-E-scooters may be ridden in bike lanes and on streets with speed limits no greater than 30 MPH. Do not ride e-scooters on sidewalks.
Also food delivery mopeds are annoying they beep at you when I AM ON THE SIDEWALK like who do you think you are
I was on Kingston once and a guy on an ebike almost ran into me who got annoyed because he said I was walking “on the wrong side of the sidewalk.” That’s not how sidewalks work! This was erev Shabbos btw.
There are no bike lanes in Crown Heights, and it is very hard to get around by car as well.
Not only for people getting knocked by them (which jnfortunately every once in a while you hear of a case in ch of someone getting really injured) But also for the rider. See, it has small wheels. One little hole or pebble on the street and you are going 20mph… fractures and all that nasty stuff minimum. Also, you think becuase yoy use helmet is everything right?having an helmet doen’t make you a superheroe that nothing happens to him. And all of the above is not mentioning the risk of bad drivers. In a car vs a motorcycle hit, not… Read more »
Try to stick to bike lanes to mitigate accidents
There are no bike lanes going from Eastern Parkway to Empire.
Also, the bike lanes are usually filled with double parked cars.
It’s already the law not to ride scooters on the sidewalk.
Don’t live in nyc
with that
There’s a big difference between a 5 minute fun scooter ride and a 20 minute walk
So your 15 minutes saved is worth sending a 5-year-old to the hospital?
A lot more people save time with scooters than hit children. This isn’t a good comparison
There should be more bike lanes
Bike lanes is realistically the only safe place to ride scooters
DONT RIDE A SCOOTER ON THE STREET
Scooters belong on the street. My son rides in the street. It goes 30mph, the same speed as a car in local traffic. Huge danger to ride on the sidewalk with pedestrians.
ever heard of a blind spot? How many people lose their lives from being hit by a scooter and then go compare how many sccoterists are killed by cars because they are in the street…
If your son drives a 30MPH scooter in the street it is against the law. You are an irresponsible parent for allowing your child to drive a scooter at a speed that can kill him.
They should be banned in the community.
If you care about your children, your health, avoid E-Scooters and encourage others to do the same.
go ban everything then. we lose more lives in our community due to car accidents, ban cars? get a life
I have to ride a scooter to get to work, but kids shouldn’t be riding them at all.
Kids had bikes and scooters for years on the sidewalk with no issues. If it was your 7 year old on the scooter would you tell them to ride on the street? I understand the frustration but accidents happen. Yes kids should be more careful when riding bikes scooters electric or not but the answer is not to put them on the street! Kids should learn safety rules and to slow down on sidewalks that should of been the message of your article not that better the rider should be on the street and get hurt there! Wishing your child… Read more »
Yes, kids have always had bikes and scooters, and they would sometimes get injured. The difference is, that our razor kick scooters didn’t reach speeds of 30 MPH and become a menace to everyone on the sidewalk
So that he won’t need an electric bike.
When I approached a menahel of our school about and told him about this danger and asked him to speak to boys about it he reponded “its an every day occurance” what an answer.i suppose as long as it didn’t happen to his son it’s not important enough to deal with.
T.y. for this article.
Maybe bike lanes aren’t such a bad idea
What happened was nothing more than an accident. As you mentioned there were two boys on the scooter. How fast could that scooter have been going with two boys on it? I teach my kids to walk with their head up and be aware. I do understand your frustration but I dont think there was a need to track down these boys parents to perhaps intimidate them or the two young boys. Accidents happen. Be careful out there.
I am very happy he tracked down the parents! The danger these vehicles present -to both pedestrians and to the riders – is very real! Anyone who is knocked over risks hitting their head, possibly sustaining a traumatic brain injury. We are not talking just scraped knees here. E-scooters, e-bikes, e-anything do not belong in the hands of young children. Every parent is responsible for educating their child about how to use any scooter, bike, etc safely. Pedestrians have RIGHT OF WAY on sidewalks. If you feel bike lanes and streets are too risky for your child to ride in… Read more »
“How fast could they have been going?”.
That’s my point, I don’t want to think what could of happened had they been going faster.
Another point: The older kid was a mesivtah bochur, unfortunately he has many friends that also ride to Yeshiva on an electric scooter.
In the parents words “it’s part of the culture”. That’s an issue.
I believe that it is more than one isolated incident. From speaking to Hatzlocha they get at least 1 call a month involving a scooter accident. It is not proportionate, or acceptable.
Go into any ER and ask a nurse or a doctor how many trauma cases come in to the er that are sevare that happened because of a scooter I have been in a scooter accident myself and only Broke my nose and a few bruises that was a miracle bh with how it happened it should have been 10 times worse I have seen 911 bring into the hospital so many critical patients that was caused by a scooter It’s no longer an accident when it’s happening every day Pedestrian getting struck by a scooter is very dangerous So… Read more »
I’ve seen a young Bocher speeding on a regular bike on the sidewalk. ZOOMED passed a non Jewish person who I overheard say “he’s about to kill someone with that bike.” This is an issue! I’m not saying that a kid can’t ride a bike on the sidewalk, but they cannot be riding recklessly! Kids should be allowed to be kids but not at the expense of other kids or anyone for that fact!
PLEASE talk to your children. At the speed the kid was going he could of injured HIMSELF if he collided with someone
Although the scooters can be dangerous, banning it doesn’t take away the danger. I see many young kids (3-7 year olds) riding bike/scooter or going ahead of their parents and always having to stop them by sthe street corners to tell them to wait for their parents. It’s not clear here if your son was near you or not… And from experience with scooters, yes some go fast not all. There is a great risk for anyone to drive on the street so your saying it’s okey for other people to get in accidents just not your kids??? Although uncomfortable… Read more »
The health of your feet?!
You know, driving the wrong way on a one-way street would get me home sooo much faster. And going 35 mph would also shorten my commuting time. Duh!!
Maybe a little less focus on “me” and a little greater attention on
“we”. Try applying the principle “if everyone behaved in the manner that I am behaving, how would that be? Would I be okay with that?”
In some cities police have found a way to ticket any rider who rides on sidewalk of busy pedestrian area.
Cant agree with u more!! This is so dangerous for pedestrians! We need to find alternate solutions to all these quick riders……
This issue really hits a raw nerve for me. Firstly it’s against the law in NYC to ride a scooter, moped, motorcycle, etc on the sidewalk . Period. Bicycles are only permitted on the sidewalk under the age of 12 years old. Moreover, if you drive, welcome to a new 3rd world country. All of these migrants are gifted motorcycles and motorbikes without license plates. They obviously don’t have to know and obey any traffic laws. They weave in and out of traffic, pass illegally at high speeds, etc. If they hit you there is no recourse. If you hit… Read more »
The author takes zero responsibility for what happened. Zero.
How is the author of this article responsible?
This issue really hits a raw nerve with me. Firstly, it is illegal in NYC to ride an electric scooter, moped, electric bike, or motorcycle on the sidewalk. Bicycles are only permitted to be ridden on the sidewalk by a child under 12 years old. If you drive in NYC welcome to the new 3rd world country. The migrants are gifted motorcycles and motorbikes without license plates. They obviously don’t have to obey traffic laws, they weave dangerously in and out of traffic, pass illegally, dont obey traffic signals, etc . If they hit you, you have zero recourse. No… Read more »
Riding an electric scooter in the street should not be something an everyday kid does just like riding a motorcycle. And you definitely shouldn’t ride it on a sidewalk. This is dangerous for everyone involved. People who buy your kids these electric scooters,don’t give in too peer pressure. This should never have been an acceptable thing.
I’ve been riding for years, and some of the worst areas I navigate every day are in CH. Riding on Empire? You have a bike line with cars double parked all over, but at least there’s a lane. Turn onto Troy? No bike lane, no lane markings at all, and a free for all of cars merging and cutting across the road as you move up to EP. It’s a similar story almost everywhere in CH. I’m not protected by a 3-ton mechanical husk, and I’m not trying to get in their way either, I’m just trying to get to… Read more »
I sympathize with all the pedestrians who have been hit or narrowly missed by these scooters. It’s important to note that many young kids are riding these scooters around Crown Heights. If we encourage everyone to start riding in the street, the situation could become even more dangerous. Does anyone want to see kids being hit by cars?
If you don’t want your child riding one, don’t let them. I think going on the street id extremely more dangerous than being on the side walk. I’m sorry your son got injured it’s not right ban scooter’s on the side walk.
I completely agree with every word David said.
“As we stepped outside, my 5 yr old son, full of excitement, ran ahead of me and out onto the sidewalk.” The 5 yr old ran onto the sidewalk, unsupervised!! A jogger could have smashed into him. Ban jogging on the sidewalk! Someone pushing a shopping cart could have banged into him. Ban using shopping carts on sidewalks! The 5 yr old child could have knocked over a frail old lady walking with her cane. Ban frail old ladies from walking on sidewalks. Wait a minute! Maybe we should allow all of the above to use sidewalks and just ban… Read more »
agree, because no injuries just scratches the scooter was not riding fast.
Young bubby here having fun on vacation in England had to try a scooter. Going uphill in traffic I hit a barrier and fell. Has flight to Israel same day so flew with a broken hand and ended up with a cast in 90 degrees in vacation in Israel.
The concept of electric scooters for children makes 0 sense
To go on the street is extremely dangerous for obvious reason and side walks are for people to walk. All the kids having it is not the reason to buy one.
Stop electric scooters before we regret it.
I am shocked and sickened by your insensitive post!!!!!
You are speaking with zero logic and common sense!!!!
We are talking about here a incident with a teenager and a 5 year old!
The teenager is responsible for practicing safety precautions with his scooter,
kids are kids especially small kids
They run around , don’t have the maturity of a teenager to think about people on the sidewalk
Shame on you.
Sounds like you are not in touch with reality
Very sad
Kids are kids! And parents are responsible for their 5 year old kids. Kop Doktor’s point was that before THIS parent blames the scooter, this parent needs to look in the mirror to see who is at fault for letting her 5 year old run out unsupervised! Sure blame everyone else for YOUR OWN shortcomings!
So many smart chachomim around here lol
How about BIKE LANES! Keep the bike and scooter riders safe and separate, keeps pedestrians safe, a little inconvenient for cars as some parking or lane mat be eliminated
too much hit & run here, wrecles driving and etc – kids will be in immidiate danger constnatly
Superwise little ones.
It IS a catch 22. My son also has an electric scooter, and just yesterday, I saw him riding on the street. Later, I told him that it’s dangerous to ride on the street. I know of someone who got killed riding a scooter on the street. A bike and scooter lane is the best idea.
We live out of town, in a largely populated frum community and neighborhood. Man many many and too many in electric scooters. Well I’m so sorry but not my son! School is a twenty min drive or half hr bus ride away. Shul is 20-30 min walk depending on which ship u choose. Mikva is 15 min walk. I am so sorry but no. Not when you are not old enough to understand the responsibilities they hold riding the weapon. This is not that different than driving a car. Mayb even more dangerous. The way these kids cross the intersection,… Read more »
now that all of the electric scooters are done with i can finally focus on getting struck by mopeds.
before discussing anything, let’s wish this boy a Refua sheina!
That being said…
For some reason I think I’m the only guy wearing a helmet while riding a scooter! It’s not ok! Everyone must wear a helmet. And btw it’s a mitzvah to as well!
Regarding mopeds, revel took all of their mopeds off the street a year ago, which already is something good.
The batteries are an enormous fire hazard. A local family had a fire in their home in the middle of the night this past year: 3 deaths, Hashem yeracheim!
Hardly anyone cares about the rising amount of home fires in the 5 boroughs caused by these batteries. They all say “It won’t happen to me!” Until it does, c”v!
Like light bulbs, stoves, kettles, shabbos candles and more.
For all those who explain why scooters are OK, I’m ann adult who drives a scooter on the road. Electric scooters are not OK for kids. If the child isn’t old enough to drive a car, or hasn’t learned how to drive a car, they also don’t know anything about safety on the road regardless of whether they are on the road or sidewalk. There’s a reason you always hear of kids getting hurt by parker cars. Yes, maybe someone opened the door to their car without seeing the kid, but was the kid scanning the road? So you want… Read more »
Think about others also not just yourself
In a city like Brooklyn, it is of utmost importance that we allow for the possibility of micro-mobility: ie; moving around with devices that aren’t cars but help you get places faster and easier than walking. The only way to make that safe is to allow the city to build protected bike lanes on as many streets as possible. The city has a proposal to build one on Kingston Ave, which unfortunately many people in the community are ignorantly fighting against. The city is currently building a protected bike lane on Bedford Ave up to Flushing. We need to look… Read more »
I belive that the boys were riding at the normal speed as you have stated yourself, and the 5 years old bumped into them, otherwise what is your point. Do you want other kids be involved in the car crashes? your child had minor scratches and zero injuries -say thank you to HaShem and pls don’t put other kids in a huge danger. the older boys riding scooter at dark!!! the possibility for hi & run will be 100%, all uninsured vehicles in CH at higher rates, major injuries when the scooter hit by the car. Teach your 5 years… Read more »
You are the parents. If you feel it’s unsafe for your child and for other people, you tell him no scooter. If he cries that his friends have one, you tell him just like everything else in life, that in our house we don’t use scooters. Sidewalks are not meant to be used for riding anything. The problem is that the parents are just as lazy as their kids. In the “olden” days, we would take our kids to school and back. Are there no school buses available for those who don’t drive. If you are saving money by buying… Read more »
we didnt have electric scooters
No lights are a huge issue.
To protect my self, I’ve been trying to train myself to walk on right side of the sidewalk!🥴