By Chana Rahmani
I don’t believe in the Shidduch Crisis. My honest opinion is that Hashem is constantly creating the world. All that happens in our lives is a direct flow of Hashem’s love and a manifestation of the purpose of creation. The fact that more people are getting married at an older age now than in years past is not a crisis; it is how Hashem is creating things to be.
That being said, there is a different crisis going on that has less to do with reality and more to do with what we believe the reality says about ourselves.
Our community has a widespread and often subconscious belief that true and valuable life begins the moment a person gets married. Although there may be no intent to send this message, it is time to start addressing that it is a sentiment being expressed and, worse, believed.
Waiting for something you feel you need and not knowing when you are going to get it is painful. And being single in a community with a core value of family life is hard. Although I don’t know how to completely alleviate the pain of this time, a large part of the pain is credited to what we believe being in this stage of life means about ourselves and our lives.
The real Shidduch crisis is not the age at which people are getting married but the belief that until one gets married, their life is even remotely less precious, valuable, worthy and purposeful than it would be if they were already married.
It is a crisis that leads to people feeling shame about showing up to a simcha alone, despair about spending shabbos without a spouse, self-pity about being someone “still single,” and feeling like until they are married, their life does not have purpose, value or worth.
As Chassidim who are charged with the mission of revealing Moshiach in the world around us, as well as in ourselves, it is our duty to face the narratives, both internal and external, that undermine the essential value, worthiness and G-dliness of our lives, and reveal the deeper truth, the G-dly truth.
Marriage is G-dly, but it is not G-d
There is a reason our community puts so much emphasis on marriage. The marriage between man and woman reflects the marriage that is constantly happening between G-d and His people, and it is the channel through which we reveal infinity in this world. Marriage is one of the most awesome things ever and raising Hashem’s children is one of the most miraculous and delicious experiences. Our souls want it so badly for a very good reason.
And yet, in the holy effort to teach the beauty and significance of marriage, we often erroneously send and receive the message that once a person is of marriageable age, moments without marriage lack the holiness and value that marriage provides.
We have taken something that is so holy and G-dly, and are subconsciously using it as a replacement for G-d.
Marriage is holy and good, and I bless everyone reading this that their true partner should appear before they even finish reading this sentence, and yet, marriage is not G-d. There is only One G-d. And the One true G-d who is the one creating a world where we desire marriage, is the same G-d Who is creating every not-yet-married person, right now.
We must start to notice if we are holding internal stories where we are idolizing marriage as the thing that will give us worth, purpose, and true life, instead of serving the One G-d who tells us that our lives have essential worth simply because He is creating us.
The holiness in marriage and raising children does not cause the moments before that experience to be any less valuable and holy.
How do I know? Because Ain Od Milvado does not have exceptions.
Ain Od Milvado Does Not Have Exceptions
As people who learn Chassidus, we all know the truth: Ain Od Milvado. There is not only One G-d, but all of reality is absolutely and completely united with Him. Every moment is no less than the loving breath of Hashem breathing reality into being.
The challenge is not only to recognize the truth of Ain Od Milvado, but to have the courage to notice the spaces in our lives that we have decided it doesn’t apply to, and then apply it there as well.
To believe that we need to wait for our life circumstances to change in order for us to be fully alive and fulfilling our divine purpose is antithetical to the unity of Hashem. This moment is as one with G-d as the moment when we receive the thing we are waiting for.
When we internalize this truth, we notice that our lives as they are manifesting right now are the biggest reason to celebrate.
Your life will not start when you get married. Your life will start the moment you decide to be present within it and you will forever feel as alive as you choose to believe that you are.
Your life is not random. It is not the result of some “system” working in some way or there being something wrong with you or the world.
There is nothing shameful about being in the exact stage of life that you are in. Your story is not the antagonist of your life. You don’t need to quickly get over this to be ok.
G-d is One, and G-d is good and the Oneness of G-d includes the you who is not married right now. The exact details of your life is Hashem flowing your soul’s purpose towards you in this exact moment.
Hashem is here. Hashem is there. Hashem is truly everywhere, including all these single moments.
So Should I Stop Desiring Marriage?
Please, do not misunderstand my words: This is not a plea to give up on getting married! On the contrary, waiting is an essential part of Hashem’s world and reflects our soul’s desire to fulfill our mission in this world. The Torah is filled with countless stories of people journeying, praying and waiting; waiting for children, spouses, and redemption. There is no shame in waiting for what your soul says you need.
But, do you think that as Chana waited for her baby, she felt the details of her current life were a mistake?! Chana knew that her barren stomach, and her desire for a child, were completely one with Hashem Himself and therefore she dared to lean into her soul’s desire and passionately ask Hashem for what she wanted!
Being present and joyful in our lives is not antithetical to asking for and receiving what we are waiting for. The truth is, the more present we are, the more we can notice that the exact path we are on is leading us directly to the thing that we are waiting for, and we can be joyfully present in the process of desiring it, and receiving it.
You have permission to wait for that which your soul desires. And you also have permission to be fully alive and in love with your life while you wait.
You are waiting, but you are not JUST waiting. I bless you to know that your desire to get married is the Divine desire of your Neshama, and to tenderly hold the feeling with passion, pride and love, as you proudly, open-heartedly and presently live within the wondrous magic of your current life.
Revealing Moshiach Through The Wait
Moshiach is actually happening. The Rebbe made it very clear to us that in addition to revealing G-d in each corner of the globe, we also have the mission of finding G-d in our own minds and hearts, in each corner of ourselves. And, if we are in a stage of life, or having a certain experience of life, then it is there that we are meant to reveal Hashem.
Shifting the stories, we are telling ourselves from believing that marriage is the determining factor of our worth, to knowing that we are essentially valuable and worthy- simply because we are One with G-d in this moment, is literally revealing Moshiach.
Geula is when we start to see ourselves and the world the way that G-d does. Geula is when we do not use spouses, babies, jobs, money, beauty, or even our performance of Mitzvos, to prove our worth, but rather, all those things are expressions who we know we truly are.
It is time to open our eyes to the truth that Hashem is not over THERE waiting to be found, but rather, Hashem is HERE; in this moment, in this body, in this life. It is time to start a revolution of teaching and believing that the details of our lives are literally the loving breath of Hashem, until we experience the ultimate revelation where we will clearly see that this has always been the truth.
It’s time to Change the Narrative
I’m writing my name on this article because I want to make it clear that believing in our lives’ inherent value, independent of what stage of life we are in, is not just a theoretical concept but is a truth I believe Hashem is waiting for us to experience.
I hope this article starts a conversation between people involved with Shidduchim, teachers and students, parents and daughters, friends, and most importantly, people and themselves.
Moshiach is imminent. It is time to get curious about the stories we are holding about ourselves that are limiting us from experiencing the truth of our lives.
What I’m asking is that as a community, we dare to be brave enough to walk to the edge of what Hashgacha Pratis actually means, and begin believing its truth about ourselves and the people who we come in contact with.
It is time not to be afraid to let our students and children know that there will NEVER be a moment in their lives that is not Hashem purposefully creating them at that moment, and that includes the time of being single.
It is time to be brave enough to add another paragraph into the speeches we give when we mention educating our children, and let people know that the same G-d who desires that we raise our children is also creating people without children with the same amount of love, intention, and purpose.
And most of all, it is time to be brave enough to check in with our own inner narratives and to notice if we are holding beliefs that say that the details of the story of our lives is somehow an exception to the Unity of Hashem.
We are divine souls in holy bodies. The details of the story of our lives are the reflection of the specific purpose of our neshama coming into this world and every single moment of our lives is precious and holy.
To anyone reading this article and not waiting to get married, I bless you to notice that these words also apply to the exact circumstance that you are in. (Ain Od Milvado- no exceptions.) Maybe you are waiting for a child, or your children are not on the path that you feel is right for them. Maybe your spouse turned out to be different than you dreamed of, or your health, career, or internal state is presenting differently than you imagined. It’s so easy to come up with a million reasons why this doesn’t apply to “me” and the situation “I” am in, but I bless you for having the courage not to exempt yourself from the Unity of Hashem. Your life is waiting.
I bless everyone reading this, that all the blessings that your souls are seeking should appear right now, and to deeply know that the same G-d who is delivering your miracle is also creating the miracle that is your life right now.
This moment is Hashem, and His arms are outstretched towards you, waiting for you to show up with the fullness of your life, including your desire, and take His hands and start dancing with Him. I bless you to dance until you notice that your hands are overflowing with the exact blessings you seek and until life starts dancing with you, and the ultimate, eternal dance takes place with Moshiach Now!
Read how Chana describes her life
An embittered woman ..
While your words sound true .. reality is ..
And the Gemara says
Of who lives with out a wife ..lives with out etc etc
It’s not so simple
That life is perfect no matter what
Chana , Shmuel’ mother, had a strong desire for a child.. but she was not embittered..
She owned her desire.. which was a godly desire.. as we see she gave her child to Hashem when he was only 3!
Here, I believe the author is making a point that we can live full godly lives.. even while owning our desires to get married.. or whatever else we desire…
וְכֵן יַעֲשֶׂה שָׁנָה בְשָׁנָה מִדֵּי עֲלֹתָהּ בְּבֵית יְהֹוָה כֵּן תַּכְעִסֶנָּה וַתִּבְכֶּה וְלֹא תֹאכַל׃
This happened year after year: Every time she went up to the House of the LORD, the other would taunt her, so that she wept and would not eat.
וַיֹּאמֶר לָהּ אֶלְקָנָה אִישָׁהּ חַנָּה לָמֶה תִבְכִּי וְלָמֶה לֹא תֹאכְלִי וְלָמֶה יֵרַע לְבָבֵךְ הֲלוֹא אָנֹכִי טוֹב לָךְ מֵעֲשָׂרָה בָּנִים׃
Her husband Elkanah said to her, “Hannah, why are you crying and why aren’t you eating? Why are you so sad? Am I not more devoted to you than ten sons?”
You are totally incorrect
Read what it says about Chana
The most qualified, holiest rabbis alive today (in physical bodies) need to (together with) the hidden tzaddikim (in Israel or wherever they are) look at All the main databases of frum singles and use their ruach hakodesh to select matches, just by looking at the names or faces. Whoever does this though, has to be an authentic hidden tzaddik with genuine ruach hakodesh, and I don’t know who that is, but someone should make this happen. They should replace the matchmakers at all the other main databases with these hidden tzaddikim who have ruach hakodesh.
Of the story of Shlomo HaMelech?!
Also, the hidden Tzadikkim aren’t eating for anonymous suggestions on col…
the way to solve the shidduch crisis is through ruach hakodesh. Maybe don’t use pictures then. If someone has ruach hakodesh names alone should work. Or female hidden tzaddikim.
Also, of course not, but someone may know someone who knows someone.
As they set out from their place above, each soul is male and female as one. Only as they descend to this world do they part, each to its own side. And then it is the One Above who unites them again. This is His exclusive domain, for He alone knows which soul belongs to which and how they must reunite.
– Zohar (Book I, 85b)
That subconscious idea of till you didnt get married your life is not valuable. There are 2 points: from a G-dly Torah perspective. Hashem says till you didnt get married your life isnt complete. Second point: our community hides behind that and exaggerates that saying , you cant live being single you need to get married. Why? Because you are proving to them their “system” is wrong! If everyone gets married and obeys the system they wont be faced with they are doing wrong and the cause of it. There is a recent idea that singles are being put into… Read more »
And to those who are married-remember when you weren’t? You, too, were once single and now you have a man in your life. Together with him please think of the singles in your life and send suggestions!
In addition, just think of the singles in your life in general. Be proactive about inviting them for meals, it’s so much more welcoming than people having to request to join your Shabbos table. Think of them for mishloach manos. Think of them if you’re planning a party (and not as a babysitter!). Being single in the frum community is often so rough when you’re constantly seeing “for couples only” and “for married men/women only.” However lonely one can imagine it is from the outside, it’s even more when you’re going through it. They are people. Treat them like people.
Don’t just reach out when you need donations for your chabad house! And keep in mind the crown heights singles too-we’d love to be invited out as well
It is incredibly draining, especially for more reserved singles or those who don’t have local family, to have to find a place to eat for every Shabbos seudah. Please reach out to them and warmly invite them. Just extending an open invite isn’t really enough- pick up the phone and specifically call or message them, let them feel personally welcome!
The real shidduch crisis is people being too picky, not tall enough, not wealthy enough, doesn’t have the best yichus. This is all goyishe and anyone who waits too long because of these inyanim is at fault.
There are many people who are not picky at all and just haven’t found someome that makes sense for them to build a life with 🙂
35 ppl and counting disagree with you. On what basis do you make this claim? Bc I’m not even getting suggestions from the shadchanim I meet with all the time…
Liked and dislikes isn’t a good argument if people agree or disagree. There are many statistical variables that can give the like/dislike button faulty results. For example, if I click the like button with my phone and then my laptop then I give the comment two likes. That’s just one example of how faulty the likes and dislikes button is.
With the like button.
So what’s your argument exactly?
Thank you for sharing your light – couldn’t agree with this more – enjoy every moment of life and have full trust in Hashem that life is unfolding exactly the way it is meant to be
Thank you for sharing the words I have felt. My path and being single has brought me closer to Hashem. I can’t question the creator, there is a reason beyond my understanding and I trust 100% it is good.
May you and all who seek their other half find them speedily and with clarity.
Wow, brilliant and so true!
Besuros Tovos for all!!
Chana your truth shines through this writing, all the blessings.
wow so brave of you, Chana, to share this in your name.
It makes your point so much stronger, that there really is nothing to be ashamed of… ever! cuz we are in Hashems loving hands at all times…!
I believe if we were all more authentic, vulnerable and speaking from our hearts, it would be easier to find our “matches”:)
The problem is, when your to comfortable as a single guy/or girl, and then (whether it’s your parents or even yourself) get that phone call from the Shadchin it’s self, we have this and that and the other for YOU…….. Just talking from my own, it’s not a very comfortable thing. And you know what? Sometimes, It’s very hard to say NO!! There are 3 categories that I can think of. 1) Plain and simple NO. (Shadchonim be mindful)……. 2) YES! Baby, it’s for me. And 3) someone out there is just pushing to do this. Answer to number three… Read more »
Definitely words to live by!
Thanks for putting the unspoken feelings into words.
I disagree with much of this. Being single is not shameful. No one sees it that way. Ppl who are single are lonely, that’s just the fact. Yes there is so much that can be accomplished being single no one argues that. But IT IS lonely. That’s the fact. You always need to find someone to go with. You don’t have a commuted partner. Your biological clock is ticking if you are a woman and many actually want to have kids and want to have a commuted partner and want to feel loved and all the other physical and emotional… Read more »
Being single is looked at as shameful?
Really?
How many times do you hear the sentence …
“Wow she’s a such a nice and pretty girl …I wonder why she isn’t married??”
As of there was something wrong with her …
ALL THE TIME
We’re obviously trying! But there’s only so much we can do (especially in a chassidic community) so me may as well enjoy the ride too
the intermarriage crisis
among the tinok shinoshba jews of today’s society
do everything you can do to prevent it!
I am 28 years old and single and I am not lonely. But the reason is because I have had to work hard to get there, with no help from the community. I would rather hang out with the friendship group I have built over years, than attend a community event. At a community event I am treated like a child, or ignored in favour of my married friends or siblings. It’s things like this that make singles feel lonely. Why go if I’m going to be made invisible anyway? If it’s hard to be single in the community then… Read more »
Wow! Amazing amazing article! Well written, to the point, obviously knows her stuff, directed towards singles, but easily applicable at all stages in one’s life, Wow!
Thank You!
To “Love how you did try to conquer darkness with light”
You argot it! 🎯
All these comments of people disagreeing is just emphasizing the importance of this Article being
Posted. I hope that all the people who commented those things and completely missed the point , are able to open their hearts, reread , take it to heart and then HOPEFULLY can learn to love their life…bc Loving life is loving Hashem
Amazing article
The world is always better when people are brave enough to stand up and say things like this.
Thank you for this article
Couldn’t agree more
People say I will start living when XYZ happens. It’s important to live now. Fully.
Thank you for sharing this message.
This article is written and expressed so clearly and beautifully!! Yasher Koach for sharing this!! So many people have to realize the truth of the matter! Hashem loves you, Hashem is orchestrating your life as perfect as it is supposed to be for your individual Neshama! Sadness and worry are antithetical to Chassidus and no matter what situation one finds themselves in, they should know they are never alone! Hashem is with you! The Rebbe is davening and beseeching Hashem on your behalf! Our job is to serve Hashem with Simcha! This reminds me of the story of the two… Read more »
Every word expressed was so amazing and inspirational!! I truly believe all those singles have special neshamos and we will see soon when Moshaich comes how special they are!
Chana,
This article is one of those breath of fresh airs. I absolutely love how you tied in your main point and made it applicable to everyone . We all have what to feel hashem is not apart of- thank you for reminding me the avodah is hard but true.
No more labels . Single.. married.. children… just Jews trying to reach their personal and ultimate geulah
So, I read this. And then I read it again. And it’s amazing. Well written, clear, structured, researched, full of wisdom and kindness, and extremely heartfelt. And yet, I struggle to find the knock on the “shidduch crisis”. Chana, you are 1000000% correct; people need to start (or for hopefully some, continue) living in a way that sees the reality of Hashem being THE existence, and not just something that happens in shul or yomim tovim. The revealed good and the not yet revealed good. The clear directions and the fuzzy bleak spiderwebs of opportunity. The married life, the not… Read more »
Couldn’t agree more. Needing to do all we can in the area of Shidduchim is not antithetical to knowing that every moment not married is completely one with hashem. It’s one and the same
It seems you are trying to make it as though we need to accept being single? It’s seems you are trying to normalize the idea? And to say that the deep human desire to be married is not “normal”? We don’t feel shame, we feel deep pain and loneliness. It’s normal. It would be weird if we didn’t. Mayb you are confusing shame with loneliness? It feels lonely to go places when so many have a spouse and someone who is “theirs” and you don’t. It may even feel shameful if you wish because it’s like you feel alone and… Read more »
You seem to have all the answers. Please tell us singles what to do to get married
Seems like you’re saying that as long as we’re single, Hashem wants us to feel pain and loneliness. I like to chose to believe that Hashem wants me to feel connection and love- no matter what stage I am in. I hope that you can open your eyes and Heart to all the love and connection that Hashem is sending your way. Hashem loves us….To say that at any point in life the “norm” would be to feel sad or lonely is so the opposite of that. You’re surrounded by love and connection Hashem loves you I hope you can… Read more »
Meaningful life does only begin at marriage. That is the way Gd said we were made to be. Why is that perspective any less Gdly then the one you suggest that we should settle that Gd wants us to marry later? Seems like hypocrisy. The pain is there and deep because your soul knows that it is not yet complete. Having everyone say its OK will not make it better. We need to think and rethink how to get our singles married not make them comfortable staying single. The fact that a single wants to ignore the pain with an… Read more »
Your value does not increase because you are a married person. Getting comfortable being single is definitely an issue but being miserable and marrying someone who is not compatible out of desperation is just as problematic. The fact is that there are many older singles for different reasons and there’s no reason to shame them
I don’t see anything in the article about singles “settling for marrying later” or “being comfortable staying single.” Nor do I see her advocating “an aspirin” unless that’s how you view Emunah and Bitachon—which would be your own problem. And meaningful life begins…at birth!
Actually, you’ve more than missed the point; you’ve warped it through the prism of your smug attitude. This writer is teaching us a valuable and timely lesson and Chaval that you’re too closed-minded to see it.
Signed,
A blessed wife, mother and grandmother
Meaningful life begins the moment soul enters body.
So well thought out, so well expressed! I think this op-ed should get the widest possible distribution. Thank you for this!
Wow Chana!! The beautifully and delicately delivered bombshells in this article! You just revolutionized my perspective on waiting. You’re absolutely right on about the absolute possibility of the desire to get married and the being confident with your unmarried present existing simultaneously! The harmony between the 2 is essential, and I believe being able to come into a marriage from that state of peace and love is SO VALUABLE!!!
Thank you for all of the Geula light you just brought into the world!
Never stop ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
(Moshiach now!)
This article needs to be pushed up to the top of collive home page!!
Thank you for sharing something so deep & vulnerable. It really hits home. I think people who do not yet have children will strongly relate to the pressure and shame that you mention is so present in our family oriented community.
People feel how you view them. If you view them as being exactly where they’re meant to be right now, perfect and valuable, whether married or not, with children or not, I promise you they will feel that from you and feel whole in your presence.
I am very pleased.
Thank you for sharing your light and describing so eloquently your point.
It’s a good point for everyone!
Everyone reading this should focus on the point, and not find reasons to not believe, because that is defeating the purpose.
Thank you so much for sharing!
This is a beautiful article. It hits the nail on the head of one of the biggest issues we have in yiddishkeit (especially within Chabad) nowadays. And I also agree, that with the mindset shift that was so eloquently described here, singles (or people going through whatever) will be happier and more calm, and thus more date-able. However, to just minimize the “shidduch crisis” to the way singles are viewed is not correct, and in fact, kind of insensitive. I’m a 26 year old single, and I pride myself on trying to live my life while going through this process.… Read more »
But I can assure you, I get the exact same treatment from certain Shadchanim, regardless of the fact that I have gezhe yichus and grew up on Shlichus. Lineage is not the reason for your hardships.
Thank you for sharing this, your message is so important. I agree, we should all be living with a full consciousness that wherever we are in life, Hashem has put us there with a divine mission in mind, something to elevate and make holy. Tapping into this is beautiful and empowering. I find that the community also treats marriage as the “finish line”.. once someone is married, they have made it in life.. Of course we should celebrate the great miracle of a marriage with a full heart. But what is even more worth celebrating? 20 years down the line… Read more »
Love this! Coming from a divorced woman I agree 100%. Getting married is half the issue. The emphasis should be placed on staying married!
So well expressed! Kol Hakavod Chana !
does anyone else think there should be no money involved in shidduchim, like paying matchmakers, and paying for the websites… the motives need to be pure for such a holy endeavor.
This is the least of our problems
Everyone needs money to support themselves. If they are not spending time with shidduchim they are working. They are amazing for spending so much time when most of their time is not paid for.
This article is so validating and true
“Our community has a widespread and often subconscious belief that true and valuable life begins the moment a person gets married…that until one gets married, their life is [somehow] less precious, valuable, worthy and purposeful than it would be if they were already married.” I am guilty of this attitude. I didn’t actually realize it until now, reading your words! This is embarrassing, but also instructive. I am equally guilty of “idolizing marriage as the thing that [gives] worth, purpose, and true life.” I shamefacedly admit to looking with pity at my former students and other fine people who happen… Read more »
Agree 100 %
Bnos Tzlofchad great example , they accomplished a change for generations and then they happily married good husbands
Beautifully written and well thought out. Couldn’t agree more.
The most difficult avoda is to truly believe that everything HASHEM does is good. When we take these ideas to heart, we start to truly believe that and are doing the hardest avoda there is.
Thank you for this reminder.
Love this chana! So true
Thank you for sharing your these kind and wise words!
Even though I’m not in the stage single, and singles can think that we just don’t get it (and maybe we don’t), I always think of all my single friends, relatives, acquaintances, co-workers, and I really care. I daven, I try to be sensitive and normal at the same time, and even send a suggestion or two. People who find themselves in this situation, know that even if we aren’t experiencing your pain the same way we do, we love you, are davening for you, believe in you and are cheering you on. May Hashem take away all types of… Read more »