ב"ה
Monday, 24 Iyyar, 5786
  |  May 11, 2026

He Just Doesn’t Get It!

From the COLlive inbox: "Many have been asking the Rabbonim here in Crown Heights, “Everyone got it already!" “It's already too late! So why the whole lockdown?” The answer they responded was, that if we can save even one Jew, we will. And that is a lesson for another topic too." Full Story

Smicha Yeshiva Holds Series on Dating & Marriage

Next Story »

Crown Heights Career Hub New Online Training Program

Subscribe
Notify of

18 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Beautiful
June 13, 2020 10:25 pm

Couldn’t agree more!!!

So true
June 13, 2020 10:28 pm

A smart phone should ONLY be used when needed; I know people who have two phones with one sim, and they only use the smart phone when needed.
(Probably more practical for bochrim who only need it when going on merkos shlichus etc.)

Ok!
June 13, 2020 10:55 pm

If you want to stand a chance educating the next generation embrace the changing and developing world, and do so by instilling the confident, and all equipt perspective of Chassidus.
Trying to push away technology out of fear of it’s power, is not a Chassidisher adgenda.
Stop educating from fear, and start educating with confidence…

Connection
Reply to  Ok!
June 13, 2020 11:31 pm

If this comment would have logic, they’re would have been what to argue about, but it lacks any speck of meaning…

Very nice but..
June 13, 2020 11:13 pm

It’s hard to judge what is a real necessity. A few years ago people had no smartphones and they survived just fine, so needing one is a very relative matter.
Also, we are super focused on the filters that limit the content of what we access but we don’t always use the time limiting filters of just simply the off button when are kids may need our attention but we’re busy catching up on the news, commenting on WhatsApp group or sending very important mivtzoyim messages for the matter, it’s just as bad.

Therapists
Reply to  Very nice but..
June 13, 2020 11:35 pm

That’s why we got this concept called “mashpia” or “personal rabbi” they’re there/here to guide us about these important issues.

Yes, but..
Reply to  Therapists
June 14, 2020 1:47 pm

Mashpiyim and therapist are often not consulted, told a half of story and in any case don’t live with us or will not “police us” when we need to make a personal decision of giving family life attention or attending the “very important matters” on our cellphones.

A healthy attitude and a great lesson
June 13, 2020 11:40 pm

Thank you for writing this. The message is nuanced and totally attainable. And it all came about thanks to your healthy Chassidishe attitude.

I respectfully disagree
June 14, 2020 12:51 am

Everything in this world is here for a reason, including the goyish world. If we are educated by constantly learning Chassidus and using that lense to see the world, there is so much we can learn from the goyim. Chassidus helps us to separate out the good from the goyish world, and elevate the nitzutzim in it. For example, we have Yiddishe dancing, gymnastics, and acting classes for children, and we make it holy by using Jewish music. It is very helpful for children as well as adults to have a healthy outlet, so they can serve hashem properly. We… Read more »

Well...
Reply to  I respectfully disagree
June 14, 2020 1:09 am

The idea that we can learn from the Non-Jewish world, while correct, must be nuanced and done with the guidance of a Mashpia. To take a Non-Jewish dance or movie and overlay Jewish music to it, wouldn’t make the dance Kosher..,.

Yikes
Reply to  I respectfully disagree
June 14, 2020 2:26 am

I’d run this hashkofa by a rov before you go around promoting this…

how many products of Chassidus do this?
Reply to  I respectfully disagree
June 14, 2020 6:46 am

Would R’ Pinye Korf read newspapers and R’ Yoel Kahn watch tv (Ch”v) to “learn from it” and “elevate it?” or, are they porush from this stuff and try their best to not have goyishe influences influence their thinking? your examples of dancing and gymnastics are great, but how many people have shmutz addictions, read kefira and loshon hora online, and at the same time believe that “they are elevating” the internet because they send out divrei torah on whatsapp (all the while texting and wasting time, for “kiruv” obviously)? The two do not shtim! ain apotropus larayos! we need… Read more »

Following the same logic
June 14, 2020 1:46 am

Being that Minyonim were deemed non essential, and groceries were deemed essential but with caution, I take it from the article that smartphones for learning torah is totally banned, but for shopping its with caution.

Got it.

Why the sarcasm?
Reply to  Following the same logic
June 14, 2020 10:45 am

Obviously in the “mashal” of covid19 the essential aspect was going to the store… in the nimshal it doesn’t need to correlate with shopping🤔

Teach values!
June 14, 2020 2:51 am

I think teaching our kids values, middos and giving a strong foundation teaches them how to deal with the temptation of the internet. Giving them strong enough values to ex something inappropriate goes much farther then blocking and filtering etc..most adults today come to a point in life where they will need unfiltered internet…for work, shlichus etc…and their values will be put to test, so imagine they have strong ones..cuz that was the focus in their education…instead telling our kids not to run in the street, let’s teach them how to cross and navigate these busy streets!

Very nice...
Reply to  Teach values!
June 14, 2020 10:47 am

But how quickly will u teach a deaf and blind person to cross? You’ll make sure they have a guide of some sort, no?
Well the internet is the same… no matter how well you teach a child to use it, they are “deaf and blind” to it’s pitfalls and need a constant guide..

Refreshing article!
June 14, 2020 6:20 am

A big ישר כח for sharing your thoughts in a very clear, down-to-earth and meaningful manner!
Hope it’s timely message will be taken to heart (and to our phones 📱:) )

Very well said
June 16, 2020 12:46 pm

Thank you for opening our eyes. If even one person is saved from the shmutz you will be zoche

X